menu-bgimg

What we can offer you

We provide detailed transactional data, cost benchmarks and in-depth analytics for participants in the wood raw materials supply chain.
  • Pricing Data
  • Benchmarks
  • Product Forecasting
  • Advisory Services
  • Analytics
Learn More

SilvaStat360 Platform

  • Price Benchmarks
  • Madison’s Lumber Reporter
  • The Beck Group’s Sawmill TQ
  • Timber Supply Analysis 
  • Global Economic Data

Explore Forest2Market's Interactive Business Intelligence Platform

Learn More

Industries

From biomass suppliers in the Baltics to pulp producers in Brazil and TIMOs in the United States, Forest2Market provides products and services for suppliers, producers and other stakeholders in the global forest products industry.

Learn More
x
 
Blog

Supreme Court: Stormwater Discharge Permits Are Not Required for Forest Roads

March 21, 2013
Author: LeAndra Spicer

The Supreme Court has reversed a U.S. Court of Appeals Ninth Circuit Court decision requiring loggers to obtain stormwater discharge permits for forest roads used during timber harvests. The Circuit Court had previously ruled the use of commercial logging roads qualified as an industrial activity for which a permit was required under the Clean Water Act.

Last December, the Supreme Court intended to hear arguments about the validity of the Circuit Court ruling. When the Environmental Protection Agency issued a rule stating logging roads were exempt from such regulation just one business day prior to the scheduled arguments, the Supreme Court was instead faced with determining if any portion of the case was left for it to decide.

Key Factors

In its decision, the Supreme Court noted rendering the case moot in light of the EPA rule was not appropriate. “A case becomes moot only when it is impossible for a court to grant any effectual relief whatever to the prevailing party.” The Supreme Court instead took the position that “a live controversy continues to exist regarding whether petitioners may be held liable for unlawful discharges under the earlier version of the Industrial Stormwater Rule.”

The Industrial Stormwater Rule defines industrial activity discharges as those “directly related to manufacturing, processing or raw materials storage areas at an industrial plant.” This classification supports the EPA’s position that temporary, outdoor logging installations are directly related to harvesting as opposed to manufacturing, processing or raw materials storage areas.

The Supreme Court also noted the EPA has consistently maintained logging roads are not subject to the same requirements as industrial facilities. In fact, the EPA has held this position for well over thirty years. As such, the Court observed neither an indication of change from a previously held stance nor a response to litigation when the EPA issued its new rule.

Additionally, best practices with respect to stormwater runoff from logging roads that are both implemented and regulated at the state level played a role in the decision. The Court made particular note of the “extensive” and “comprehensive” practices the state of Oregon uses to manage such runoff. On past occasions, Congress had instructed the EPA to collaborate with state officials to develop such best management practices.

Next Steps

Though the Supreme Court’s decision is good news for forest owners, it is unlikely this is the last they will hear of the matter. Prior to the decision, National Alliance of Forest Owners (NAFO) President and CEO Dave Tenny shared concerns (read more here at Forest2Market blog) that litigators would persist in their quest to require permits regardless of the Court’s decision. Legislation aimed to clarify, once and for all, that forest roads are not point sources of pollution appears the only practical way stop an ongoing cycle of litigation.

Back to Blog

You May Also be Interested In

February 20, 2020
Wood Pulp is a Sustainable Cotton Replacement, but is it Profitable?
Ecological trends and concern over pollution and climate change are putting more and more pressure on the global...
Continue Reading
January 22, 2020
US Forest Industry Performance: December 2019
US forest industry performance in November and December was recently reported by both the US government and the...
Continue Reading
January 09, 2020
Australia’s Catastrophic Wildfires are Unprecedented
Australia’s current forest fires are unprecedented in several respects: They are unparalleled in scale and extent,...
Continue Reading